Fresh + Local: the challenge of butternut squash

Oct 28th, 2014 | by Eat Drink Indy | Cook, News

By Carolyn Doyle

Call it the butternut backlash.

Butternut squash soup – once a trendy option – is now as ubiquitous as the chicken Caesar salad.

That doesn’t necessarily make it bad…but it does ensure that a lot more mediocre renditions of the popular soup are out there. I even saw a social media post recently to that effect that we should all just back away from the butternut squash soup for a while.


I’m up for the challenge, because this winter squash can do a lot more than soup if you give it a chance.  Not only is it a great local food option in the colder months, it’s full of beta carotene and is a lot more versatile than you might imagine.

I think one reason we tend to shy away from using it in everyday cooking is that butternut squash is hard to handle. Peeling and attempting to disassemble a roly-poly tough-skinned winter squash with a chef’s knife is not something everyone wants to tackle after getting home from work.

So when you decide you do have the time to take on this job, here’s a tip: prepare a couple of squash and save the long “trunk” portion of one to peel and cut into long thin planks. Cut the planks into quick-cooking sticks. (I cut mine 2-3 inches long and ¼ to ½ inch wide and tall.) Placed in a container in the fridge, they’re ready to be quickly sautéed and tossed with pasta or served on their own…or in this simple and surprising combo.

Follow me on Twitter: @CarolynDDoyle or Facebook: Carolyn Doyle Cooking.

Butternut Broccoli

Makes 1 serving

½ cup butternut squash sticks

¾ cup broccoli florets

1 teaspoon butter

½ teaspoon minced garlic

Salt and pepper to taste

Place broccoli and squash on separate sides of a microwave-safe plate, sprinkle with 1-2 tablespoon water and cover with wax paper. Microwave about 1 minute.

In a skillet melt the butter; when it starts to sizzle, add the squash and it cook until it begins to brown, 2-3 minutes. (Don’t stir too often, give it some time to develop color.) Add the broccoli and a little salt and pepper to taste. Cook, stirring, 1 minute. Add the garlic and cook another 30 seconds or so. Taste; adjust seasoning and serve.








Jolene’s Blog

Happy New Year

It was a loooong 2017, wasn’t it? But here we are, on a bright, clear January day, with a bright new year ahead of us. I’m looking forward to better days ahead, and I wish you all the same!


Where to eat now


611 East St., Indianapolis

Cannon Ball Brewing

1702 Bellefontaine St., Indianapolis


Gallery Pastry Shop
1101 E. 54th St., Indianapolis