Fresh + Local: the challenge of butternut squash

Oct 28th, 2014 | by Eat Drink Indy | Cook, News

By Carolyn Doyle

Call it the butternut backlash.

Butternut squash soup – once a trendy option – is now as ubiquitous as the chicken Caesar salad.

That doesn’t necessarily make it bad…but it does ensure that a lot more mediocre renditions of the popular soup are out there. I even saw a social media post recently to that effect that we should all just back away from the butternut squash soup for a while.


I’m up for the challenge, because this winter squash can do a lot more than soup if you give it a chance.  Not only is it a great local food option in the colder months, it’s full of beta carotene and is a lot more versatile than you might imagine.

I think one reason we tend to shy away from using it in everyday cooking is that butternut squash is hard to handle. Peeling and attempting to disassemble a roly-poly tough-skinned winter squash with a chef’s knife is not something everyone wants to tackle after getting home from work.

So when you decide you do have the time to take on this job, here’s a tip: prepare a couple of squash and save the long “trunk” portion of one to peel and cut into long thin planks. Cut the planks into quick-cooking sticks. (I cut mine 2-3 inches long and ¼ to ½ inch wide and tall.) Placed in a container in the fridge, they’re ready to be quickly sautéed and tossed with pasta or served on their own…or in this simple and surprising combo.

Follow me on Twitter: @CarolynDDoyle or Facebook: Carolyn Doyle Cooking.

Butternut Broccoli

Makes 1 serving

½ cup butternut squash sticks

¾ cup broccoli florets

1 teaspoon butter

½ teaspoon minced garlic

Salt and pepper to taste

Place broccoli and squash on separate sides of a microwave-safe plate, sprinkle with 1-2 tablespoon water and cover with wax paper. Microwave about 1 minute.

In a skillet melt the butter; when it starts to sizzle, add the squash and it cook until it begins to brown, 2-3 minutes. (Don’t stir too often, give it some time to develop color.) Add the broccoli and a little salt and pepper to taste. Cook, stirring, 1 minute. Add the garlic and cook another 30 seconds or so. Taste; adjust seasoning and serve.








Jolene’s Blog

Learn spice blending from a master

I hear about a lot of cool food-related events, but I can’t always get to them or even just get them posted. But this one is too good to miss. Cardinal Spirits in Bloomington is hosting master spice blender Lior Lev Sercarz, author of The Art of Blending and The Spice Companion and owner of … more »


Where to eat now

Long Branch

2205 N. Delaware St., Indianapolis


1217 E. 16th St., Indianapolis


Mile Square Bistro

443 N. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis