Chefs’ Night Off goes vegetarian for latest dinner

Jul 15th, 2014 | by Eat Drink Indy | Events, News, Restaurants

By Will Carroll

Sportswriter and EatDrinkIndy columnist WIll Carroll

Sportswriter and EatDrinkIndy columnist WIll Carroll

Chefs’ Night Off took over the City Market on Sunday night, and it was my first opportunity to take part in this exciting new concept, where several area chefs get to show off in a showcase dinner. I was astounded by the creativity and the taste of the food.

Why was this my first? I’m a vegetarian, and most tasting menus, especially special dinners like what CNO puts on, just aren’t vegetarian friendly. This dinner gave me the chance to take part. Most of the chef’s were from Cerulean, and the meal did have a organization that was understandable. There were four courses, and with 90 people to serve (plus steps!), the servers and chefs did an outstanding job.

A riff on Waldorf salad by Cerulean executive chef Alan Sternberg. Photo by Will Carroll

A riff on Waldorf salad by Cerulean executive chef Alan Sternberg. Photo by Will Carroll

The first course was a play on a Waldorf salad. Cerulean executive chef Alan Sternberg told a story about how he got his start at Ruby Tuesday and played off their pumpernickel croutons to make a “dirt” for this salad. It featured very fresh tomatoes, celery and a crunchy mushroom that was made to remind us vegetarians of pork. It worked extremely well as a starter.

The second dish was simply brilliant. Again using local produce, Cerulean sous chef Jessica Selkirk made an asparagus dumpling. It was placed on a lemon ricotta that was light and refreshing, playing off the bite of the asparagus. On top was an innovative watermelon prosciutto. Selkirk told me that she did it with a simple dehydrator. All I know is I need more watermelon prosciutto in my life!

Asparagus dumpling by Cerulean sous chef Jessica Selkirk.

Asparagus dumpling by Cerulean sous chef Jessica Selkirk. Photo by Will Carroll

The third dish was perhaps the most challenging, but came together well. Jimmy Edwards, from Chicago’s Acadia, roasted cauliflower in curry, added a salad of raisins and garbanzo beans, then put fresh naan on harissa to give it a peppery finish. There was a purple puree that no one at my table could identify by taste, with my guess being broccoli. Instead, Edwards had used purple cauliflower to give the dish an unusual bright spot. While there were several unusual components — and I’m not normally a cauliflower fan — the dish came together well.

Roasted curry cauliflower by Acadia chef Jimmy Edwards.

Roasted curry cauliflower by Acadia chef Jimmy Edwards. Photo by Will Carroll

Dessert was gorgeous and tasty. Cerulean pastry chef Peter Schmutte put together a geometric dessert that combined a cherry hibiscus gelato on a basil cake alongside a chocolate verbena. Stewed cherries gave a burst of flavor that amplified the gelato. I’d have never thought to pair cherry and basil, but the dessert capped the night perfectly.

Dessert by Cerulean pastry chef Peter Schmutte.

Basil cake with cherry hibiscus gelato by Cerulean pastry chef Peter Schmutte. Photo by Will Carroll

Daredevil Brewery was also a part of the dinner, with several of their beers on tap at the Tomlinson Tap Room. While I like their flagship Liftoff IPA, I got the chance to try their Vacation Kolsch for the first time. It was a nice refreshing beer with a bit of a vegetal taste rather than the more often seen citrus. It was very clean, very drinkable and a good pairing with my excellent meal.

The next Chefs’ Night Off dinner is already on sale and will take place at Cerulean. The crazy cats have plenty more in the planner, and it sounds like they’ll do another vegetarian version down the line as well. Until then, I’ll have to just look on with envy, knowing just how good it can be.

You can find Will Carroll’s sport reporting on Bleacher Report and follow him on Twitter @injuryexpert.

Jolene’s Blog

A local food community cookbook

If you’ve followed me over the years, you know that I love community cookbooks. I have a variety of favorites, and I always feel like this type of cookbook is where you’ll find the recipe that real people are really making. These are the dishes that people bring to their friends when they need comfort, … more »


Where to eat now

Hedge Row

350 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis

Sugarfire Smokehouse

24 W. Washington St., Indianapolis


Oca (inside Sun King Brewing)
135 N. College Ave., Indianapolis